How This Works

A Simple, Easy, and Secure Way to Sell Your Items

Follow these three straightforward steps to sell your toys, collectibles, and more:

  1. Review our buy list and submit your sell order online.
  2. After we confirm your order via email, ship or drop off your items for evaluation.
  3. We inspect and pay you within 1 week of receipt (often sooner).

Step 1: Finding Items & Submitting Your Sell Order

Our site uses a familiar shopping cart system - just like buying online, but you're selling to us.

Browse or search for items you want to sell:

  • Option 1: Use the category links to view all items we're currently purchasing.
  • Option 2: Use the search bar at the top of every page - search by product name or UPC code.

When you find an item, click the "Sell Item Now" button to add it to your cart. Adding items doesn't commit you - you can adjust quantities, remove items, or continue browsing.

When ready, click "My Basket" (top right on any page) to review your cart and finalize your sell order.

  • Check your basket anytime via the "My Basket" link.
  • Easily edit quantities or remove items before checkout.

Handling Large Collections

If your collection requires multiple boxes, that's perfectly fine! We recommend processing **one order per box** for faster, more efficient handling. Multiple orders are welcome.

Important: Each box must contain at least $30.00 worth of merchandise to qualify for a prepaid shipping label. Pack your box as you build the order online - this helps ensure everything fits, avoids last-minute searching, and streamlines the process.

Step 2: After Submitting Your Order

Once checkout is complete, you'll receive an order number and automated email confirmation.

A team member will review your submission and reply via email to confirm we want to purchase the items, along with shipping instructions and options.

Because collectibles vary in condition, we evaluate everything upon arrival to ensure it meets our requirements (e.g., most items must be in mint condition, and we verify authenticity). If adjustments are needed (price changes or non-accepted items), we'll contact you first to discuss options.

No obligation: If you're not satisfied with any changes, simply let us know - we'll arrange the best possible return shipping at no extra cost to you.

Price lock: Prices can fluctuate daily, so you have 14 days from order submission to ship your items and secure the quoted price.

Step 3: When Your Shipment Arrives

We'll contact you within 1 week (usually sooner) after receiving and processing your items to confirm everything was checked in.

Payment is then released via one of two easy methods:

  • PayPal - fast and secure transfers
  • BBToyStore.com store credit - includes a 25% bonus added to your total

For complete details, visit our Payments, Shipping & Packaging page.

High success rate: 99% of submissions are accepted successfully.

Note: You must be 18+ to place a sell order.

Questions? See our Frequently Asked Questions page for more info.

If you run into any issues placing an order or have concerns about the process, please contact us - we're here to help!

Sell with confidence - fast, fair, and guaranteed.